Summary

The Other Roe is a feature-length documentary.

THE OTHER ROE explores the lesser-known but equally crucial legal battle that unfolded alongside Roe v. Wade. While Roe focused on the fundamental right to privacy, Doe v. Bolton took on the excessive restrictions surrounding abortion access in the state of Georgia. Doe v. Bolton, spearheaded by Margie Pitts Hames, fought against regulations that allowed abortions only for cases involving rape, incest, or a threat to a woman’s life. Through interviews, rare footage, and exclusive insights, THE OTHER ROE will examine how these cases intersected to form a comprehensive argument for reproductive rights, and why it’s crucial to understand both cases in today’s political climate.

In the vein of hard-hitting and revelatory documentaries like All In: The Fight for Democracy and 13th, which respectively peel back the layers of voter suppression and the intersection of race, justice, and mass incarceration in the United States, our film seeks to uncover another pivotal yet underrepresented battle in America’s ongoing struggle for civil rights and equality. THE OTHER ROE investigates the heart of the legal fight for women’s reproductive rights through the lens of the landmark Supreme Court case, Doe v. Bolton, alongside its more famous counterpart, Roe v. Wade.

Emotional, cinematic, and rooted in subjective verite, THE OTHER ROE aims to educate & ignite its audience on the historical importance of Doe v. Bolton and illuminate the ongoing challenges faced in pursuing reproductive rights and women’s autonomy. In doing so, the film adopts a tone of urgency and advocacy, echoing the impactful storytelling and profound insights of its predecessors, “All In” and “13th,” to engage, inform, and inspire action among viewers. This documentary stands as a testament to the courage of those like Margie Pitts Hames, who fought tirelessly in the courts to secure freedoms that continue to impact lives today and serves as a reminder of the vigilance required to protect those freedoms for generations to come.

ACT ONE: 

The story begins in the shadows of a profound legal and societal reversal—the Supreme Court’s 2022 Dobbs v. Jackson decision, which nullified Roe v. Wade and Doe v. Bolton, plunging us into a reflection on the past. The nation reacts to the news, and we see women and men tearful and on fire to restore these rights.  Celebration ensues among the pro-lifers, and we see pure agony for the pro-abortionists.  What happens to women and girls if 100 years of rights are stripped away?  Will life imitate art like in The Handmaid’s Tale?  Will the current Supreme Court overturn their own overturn?  Are all human rights advancements at risk?

At this pivotal moment, we revisit the legacy of Margie Pitts Hames, a civil rights lawyer whose efforts in the late 1960s and early 1970s became a beacon in the fight for reproductive rights. Through file footage, we hear/see snippets of Margie arguing in front of the Supreme Court.  This was a time when the systemic disenfranchisement of women and people of color was rampant, and Hames’s battle was not just for abortion rights but against broader societal inequalities. Roe v. Wade, while a landmark, addressed the right to choose. Still, Doe v. Bolton—through Hames’s legal prowess—cast a wider net, protecting women, physicians, and healthcare providers alike, ensuring a more comprehensive approach to reproductive healthcare. The film introduces contemporary figures, activists, and legal minds who have taken up the mantle, drawing inspiration from Hames’s legacy to navigate the post-Dobbs landscape. 

ACT TWO: 

Legal Drama and Differences

As we investigate Doe v. Bolton, the focus sharpens on Hames’s legal strategy, which aimed to secure reproductive rights and challenge the systemic barriers facing women and people of color. She even verbally fought Ruth Bader Ginsberg over strategy. The film elucidates the distinctions between Roe and Doe, emphasizing Hames’s foresight in addressing broader healthcare access issues, thus highlighting the layered complexities of the fight for equality. The narrative deepens as we explore the conspiracy theories and extremist ideologies that have fueled resistance to reproductive rights, revealing a fear among some white Americans of being outnumbered by people of color. This fear, intertwined with extremist views against interracial unions, creates a backdrop against which the battle for reproductive rights unfolds.

Impact and Threats

The aftermath of the Supreme Court rulings is explored, showcasing their transformative effects and the current threats posed by the Dobbs v. Jackson decision. This transition underscores the recurring themes of disenfranchisement and the cyclical nature of the struggle for rights, mirroring the societal challenges of the 60s and 70s. The heart of our story delves deep into the legal labyrinth and societal tumult of Doe v. Bolton, where Margie Pitts Hames’s strategic genius shone brightest. Amidst the backdrop of a society grappling with the aftermath of the civil rights movement, Hames’s class action lawsuit not only sought to affirm women’s autonomy but also to shield those who supported their choices—healthcare providers facing an onslaught of legal and physical threats.

The narrative unfolds through the turbulent times of the 1988 DNC Caucus,when abortion clinics became battlegrounds, echoing the struggles of today, where providers navigate a maze of restrictions and hostility reminiscent of past sieges. Here, the documentary explores the sinister underbelly of these conflicts—a conspiracy fueled by extremist ideologies, claiming a fear of demographic shifts that threaten to undermine white supremacy. Such theories, intertwined with abhorrent narratives like the “mark of Cain,” unveil the deep-seated racism that complicates the fight for reproductive rights.  As Hames’s story unfolds, the film reveals the broader implications of her legal battles—how they intersected with fights for racial equality and justice, showcasing her as a figure who championed reproductive rights and stood against the systemic oppression of marginalized communities. Her legacy is a testament to the enduring struggle for rights in the face of societal and political upheaval, underscoring the complexities of the fight for reproductive freedom.

Violence & Agendas

The narrative confronts the aggressive tactics of anti-abortionists, revealing a disturbing parallel to the broader disenfranchisement efforts of the past, now resurfacing under the shadow of a Trumpian court in 2024. This era sees a rise in conservatism, fueled by sectors of extremist Christianity, challenging the very fabric of democracy and human rights.

In the face of these daunting challenges and divisive ideologies, the film shifts its focus toward Generation Z’spotential to herald a significant change. It poses a hopeful future where the upcoming generation, known for its diversity and inclusivity, could play a pivotal role in reshaping societal norms and attitudes. GEN Z stands as a beacon of hope against ongoing struggles for equality and justice by exercising their right to vote and fostering a consciousness transcending color lines.  

However, the big reveal demonstrated through interviews with Gen Z activists shows that all Gen Z activists are not as liberal as the media portrays.  Gender roles…A louder, “God-fearing” community is warring with abortionists as well.  The very topic of abortion is a platform that divides US political party lines.  Freedom and democracy are at stake.

ACT THREE:

As the narrative transitions back to the present, the question arises: Who is the Margie Pitts Hames of today, and how can the fight for reproductive rights be reignited? These modern-day champions, armed with the lessons of the past, are spearheading efforts to restore and protect abortion rights through legal challenges, grassroots activism, and public advocacy.  Amid the resurgence of restrictive laws and the shadow of a divided Supreme Court, the documentary highlights the critical role of public opinion and the power of the vote. Generation Z emerges as a beacon of hope, with its inclusivity and progressive values, potentially pivotal in reshaping the political and social fabric to embrace reproductive rights fully.

In conclusion, the film doesn’t just recount the history of Margie Pitts Hames and her monumental contributions; it serves as a rallying cry for continued activism and legal advocacy. It’s a reminder that the fight for reproductive rights, intertwined with battles against racial and gender inequality, requires relentless pursuit and unwavering courage. As Hames’s legacy illuminates the path, the documentary calls upon a new generation to lead the charge, advocating for a future where the rights and dignity of all are upheld. Through this lens,  THE OTHER ROE honors the past and inspires a vision for reclaiming and securing reproductive freedom in the years to come

Why This Film Matters:

While Roe v. Wade is widely recognized, Doe v. Bolton remains underrepresented in public discussions about reproductive rights, even though it significantly expanded the scope of legal abortion access. This film aims to educate audiences on the combined impact of both cases, showing how Roe provided the foundation and Doe addressed the barriers in accessing abortion care. With reproductive rights once again under threat, THE OTHER ROE serves as a timely reminder of the hard-won battles of the past and the work still left to be done.

Your support will help ensure this story reaches a global audience, making sure the history of Doe v. Bolton is preserved and its lessons continue to inform today’s movement for reproductive justice.

How Doe v. Bolton and Roe v. Wade Work Together:

Roe v. Wade is known for establishing a woman’s constitutional right to abortion under the right to privacy. However, Roe alone could not prevent states from imposing various restrictions. It was Doe v. Bolton that took on these excessive restrictions in Georgia, addressing mandatory hospital stays, requirements for multiple physicians’ approval, and limitations on abortion eligibility. While Roe provided the constitutional foundation, Doe ensured that this right wasn’t undermined by state-imposed barriers.

The two cases were decided on the same day—January 22, 1973—with Justice Harry Blackmun writing the majority opinion for both. Together, they defined the legality and accessibility of abortion in America, with Roe focusing on the right and Doe focusing on accessibility and equity in that right.

In THE OTHER ROE, we’ll explore:

The legal arguments of Doe v. Bolton and its role in dismantling restrictive state regulations.

The personal story of Margie Pitts Hames, who courageously took on this case in Georgia.

How the outcomes of Roe and Doe worked in tandem to create a lasting framework for reproductive rights in America.

What the rollback of these protections could mean for modern reproductive justice.

Why We Need Your Support:

To tell this story fully, we need to raise $150,000 to fund  production, and post production. Every dollar will go toward bringing THE OTHER ROE to audiences across the globe. Here’s how your contribution will be used:

Production: Capturing interviews, filming on-location, and creating a visual story that honors the gravity of these historic events.

Archival Research and Licensing: Sourcing footage, legal documents, and historical material related to both Doe v. Bolton and Roe v. Wade.

Post-Production: Editing, sound design, and scoring to bring this documentary to life.

Distribution and Marketing: Ensuring THE OTHER ROE reaches audiences everywhere, from schools and libraries to film festivals and streaming platforms.

Your support will help us preserve this important piece of history and make it accessible to a wide audience, helping others understand the combined significance of Roe and Doe in reproductive rights.

Meet the Team:

Wendy Eley Jackson – Director/ProducerWendy Eley Jackson is an award-winning filmmaker, educator, and advocate known for her work in storytelling that highlights social justice and underrepresented voices. With over 25 years of experience in film and media, Wendy has produced and directed documentaries that focus on themes of community, resilience, and change. She is the founder of Auburn Avenue Films, a production company dedicated to creating powerful narratives that explore race, culture, and social issues. Wendy currently serves as an Lecturer at UC Santa Barbara, where she inspires the next generation of storytellers. Through her films and teachings, she continues to impact audiences, fostering awareness and empathy on a global scale.

Elisa Gambino – Producer

Elisa Gambino is an Emmy® Award-winning producer and director renowned for her compelling storytelling and journalistic acumen. She began her career as a producer in CNN’s Rome bureau, covering significant global events such as the fall of the Berlin Wall, the Gulf War, and the collapse of the Soviet Union. Her work in Somalia earned her a News and Documentary Emmy Award. Elisa has also executive-produced several acclaimed documentary shorts, including the Oscar®-nominated “A Love Song for Latasha” (2021). In 2022, she directed “Wasteland,” a CBS News docuseries for Paramount+ that investigates the detrimental effects of wastewater on American communities. The series prompted the largest environmental justice grant in New York State’s history.

​Neal Broffman – Director of Photography & Editor

Neal Broffman is an accomplished filmmaker and director known for his work in documentaries that explore human resilience and social issues. With a background in journalism, Neal spent years as a cameraman and producer for CNN, covering significant global events across Europe, Africa, and the Middle East. He later co-founded One Production Place Films with his wife, Elisa Gambino, producing stories that emphasize community and social impact. Neal’s feature-length documentary Welcome to Pine Lake examines race and privilege in a small Southern town and reflects his dedication to revealing untold narratives. His work combines powerful visuals with compelling storytelling, shedding light on complex social dynamics and fostering deeper understanding and empathy.

Donia Hames Robinson – Executive Producer

Donia Hames Robinson is a dedicated advocate, producer, and storyteller with a focus on social justice and community empowerment. With a background in legal advocacy and nonprofit work, she has championed initiatives that address systemic inequalities and support marginalized communities. Inspired by her mother, Margie Pitts Hames—an attorney who played a pivotal role in the landmark Doe v. Bolton case—Donia continues her family’s legacy through projects that shed light on important social issues. Her work in film and media emphasizes storytelling as a tool for change, blending personal history with a commitment to creating a more equitable society.

Ann Rose – Executive Producer

Ann Rose is a passionate advocate and leader in reproductive rights and social justice, known for her longstanding commitment to empowering women and supporting marginalized communities. With years of experience in nonprofit work and public advocacy, Ann has championed efforts that safeguard access to healthcare and reproductive autonomy. Her work emphasizes the importance of education, policy change, and grassroots mobilization in creating equitable opportunities for all. Driven by a deep dedication to justice, Ann has become a respected voice in the fight for reproductive rights, inspiring others to join her in building a fairer, more inclusive society.

Samuel Pollard – Executive Producer

Sam Pollard is an acclaimed filmmaker, editor, and producer celebrated for his profound contributions to African American history and social justice narratives. With over four decades in the industry, Pollard’s work spans impactful collaborations with luminaries like Spike Lee, including editing Mo’ Better Blues and Jungle Fever. He has directed and produced numerous award-winning documentaries such as MLK/FBI, Four Little Girls (Academy Award-nominated for Best Documentary), and When the Levees Broke. Pollard’s films are recognized for their depth, meticulous research, and powerful storytelling, bringing critical historical narratives to life. His work has earned him multiple Emmy Awards and multiple prestigious Peabody Award, solidifying his reputation as a pioneering voice in documentary filmmaking dedicated to amplifying Black voices and chronicling pivotal American stories.

Cheryl Bayer – Co-Producer

Cheryl Bayer is a seasoned producer, entrepreneur, and creative visionary with a remarkable career in film, television, and digital media. As the founder of Living Popups, an innovative media company specializing in augmented reality experiences, Cheryl has pioneered new ways of storytelling that bridge technology and entertainment. With extensive experience in content development, she has collaborated on projects across major networks and platforms, crafting compelling narratives that engage audiences in fresh, immersive ways. Known for her forward-thinking approach and leadership, Cheryl continues to push boundaries in the industry, blending creativity with cutting-edge technology to transform how stories are told and experienced.

Risks and Challenges:

Documentaries like THE OTHER ROE require extensive research, licensing, and the involvement of key experts and participants. Challenges in securing archival footage and interviews may arise, but with your support, we are committed to bringing this essential story to completion. We pledge to keep our backers updated on all developments.

Spread the Word!

Even if you’re unable to contribute financially, you can help bring THE OTHER ROE to life by sharing our campaign. Together, we can ensure the story of Doe v. Bolton is heard and its legacy preserved.

Join us in telling the story of THE OTHER ROE, and help us make history known so that it is never forgotten.